makemachine.ai
🔥

BBQ Modular Grill

I want to design a modular grill. Instead of one sealed block, it is made of separate parts that can each be bought on their own online. That opens up a new kind of gift: a group of friends or family can give one grill together, and every person pays for one part. Each part is engraved with the name of the person who gave it, and each part can be ordered in its own colour. It also solves a common problem: when a single part of a grill breaks, the whole thing is often useless. With a modular grill, I can simply buy the missing part and keep the rest. After the design, I plan to build a website where people order individual modules. The payment can be split between the givers. The grill can be delivered complete to the person receiving it, or the parts can go to the givers, who bring them along and put the grill together at the handover.

Open hardware, CERN-OHL-W 2.0

Project log: 5 updates as text

Sourcing v1.0

Sourcing for the BBQ Modular Grill 57 cm, v1.0 (CAD v1.0, rough layout) is complete as a draft. One set costs about 1,400 EUR net excluding labour (18.6 h, 1,395 EUR at 75 EUR/h); 10 sets come to at most about 12,200 EUR and 100 sets to at least about 79,200 EUR. Most parts have a source link, but second-source prices are mostly not read, 29 of 61 item codes have no second source, and several parts are still placeholders. Nothing has been ordered; the order draft is ready for review.

  • One set: 1,399.81 EUR net (core M1–M9 1,380.52 EUR, LH add-on 19.29 EUR); no VAT, shipping or labour.
  • 10 sets: upper bound 12,198.10 EUR; 100 sets: floor 79,249.00 EUR (estimator prices for five turned parts).
  • Labour 18.6 h = 1,395 EUR at 75 EUR/h is excluded from all costs.
  • Order draft with 31 purchase lines (reference MM13-228-SO); nothing is ordered.

Mechanical CAD v1.0

BBQ Modular Grill, Mechanical CAD v1.0: The modular kettle grill: ten modules on one stainless hub ring

A complete parametric 3D model of the modular 57 cm charcoal kettle is ready: 146 parts in ten modules around one stainless hub ring with 12 sockets. Legs, handles, side table and lid holder click in with snap buttons, and the bowl locks with a 15° bayonet turn. All 10 operating and assembly states are free of collisions, the grill tips only beyond 10.4° in every load case, and hand calculations give a safety factor of at least 1.67 on 29 load paths. A hand-made one-off prototype of the nine core modules would cost about 2,708 € net, far above the 760–1,150 € retail target, mostly because of …

  • One stainless hub ring with 12 sockets carries every module; no tools needed at home
  • 146 parts, 33.8 kg, cooking height 790 mm, height 1,131 mm (1,333 mm with lid holder)
  • 0 collisions in 10 states; tip angle ≥ 10.4° in all 5 load cases
  • 29 hand calculations, lowest safety factor 1.67 (leg spigot)

Patent (IP) v1.0

BBQ Modular Grill, Patent (IP) v1.0: Figure 1: side elevation of the assembled grill

A draft Singapore patent application for the modular barbecue is ready for review, but not filed: specification with 13 claims (independent claims 1 and 11), abstract (113 words), five drawings, Form PF1 draft and a corrected deadline table. Two prior-art searches with general terms found no document that, in the passages read, shows the full combination of a hub ring, uniform spring-detent sockets and a bowl bayonet. Several documents overlap in part, most of all a granted side-table patent (US12667224B2). Novelty is therefore provisional, and the full texts and legal status of the closest …

  • Draft Singapore application ready for review: 13 claims, abstract 113 words, 5 drawings, PF1 draft. Not filed.
  • Claims cover the hub ring with uniform spring-detent sockets, the bowl bayonet to the ring, and a servicing method (claim 11).
  • Two prior-art searches: no document shows the full combination in the passages read; partial overlaps for side tables, accessory rails and a nested ring.
  • Check first: US12667224B2 (side table on friction-fit posts, granted), US12551009B2 (granted), US20260047719A1 (modular grill, published), EP4087456B1 (granted), and the unidentified kettle-leg …

Research v1.0

The market research covers four points: repairable grills and spare parts, group-gift platforms, engraving and coating for small series, and EU grill norms. Only Weber and Napoleon sell most parts of a 57 cm kettle separately with EU prices, and Weber promises parts only for the warranty period. Existing group-gift platforms pool money and collect digital messages; none found personalises a physical item per contributor and ships it to several givers. Standard powder coating is rated 100 °C as a conservative figure, not the 150 °C in the concept, and the Weber bowl and lid prices used as …

  • Only Weber and Napoleon sell most 57 cm kettle parts separately in the EU; Napoleon's parts promise differs between sources.
  • Weber promises spare parts for the warranty period only; the kettle body and lid carry 10 years warranty.
  • The concept's Weber bowl (249.99 to 289.99 EUR) and lid (139.99 to 219.99 EUR) anchors are not shown on the shop page checked today; re-check before using the target prices.
  • Group-gift platforms charge 1.9 to 2.9 % plus a fixed fee, and offer digital messages only; no physical per-contributor personalisation found.

Concept v1.0

BBQ Modular Grill, Concept v1.0: Option 2 – Ring-hub kettle: group assembly in 6 steps (animation)

Recommendation: Option 2 – Ring-hub kettle, a 57 cm charcoal kettle in which legs, handles, side table and add-ons all click into one stainless hub ring without tools, while the bowl drops in and locks with a short turn. Each of its 9 core modules can be bought, engraved with the giver's name, coloured and shipped on its own, so a group can give one grill together, and every module can later be replaced by a spare that fits all the others. Target prices are estimates, and Ben decides the final numbers: about 40–220 € per module, about 760–1,150 € for the core set, or roughly 85–130 € per …

  • Recommended: Option 2 – Ring-hub kettle. One socket type on a stainless ring carries legs, handles, side table and add-ons.
  • 9 core modules: hub ring, leg set, bowl, fire set, cooking grate, lid, handle pair, ash set, side table. Add-ons use 4 free sockets.
  • Every module has one fixed name field: deep laser engraving on stainless, wood or powder coat, and a movable stainless name badge on the enamel lid and bowl.
  • Colour: enamel palette for lid and bowl, powder palette for legs and table frame. Ring, grates, fire and ash parts stay neutral.