makemachine.ai
🚲

Rooficle

I want to develop a light, efficient and affordable e-bike that can be used legally on public roads in Singapore. Its core is an integrated, aerodynamic roof with solar cells that protects riders from strong sun and frequent tropical rain, while the solar cells improve energy efficiency and range. The roof should be part of the whole product, not a heavy, bulky or unsafe add-on. First I will check regulatory feasibility and concept variants: motor, pedal assistance, top speed, weight, dimensions, registration and certification, the requirements of Singapore's LTA, and how a roof affects the legal vehicle class. Legal compliance is a hard requirement. I also want to calculate, in a way anyone can follow, the realistic solar yield in Singapore, roof area, weight, wind loads, stability, centre of gravity, weather protection, ergonomics, battery system and energy use. Then comes an attractive product design, followed by CAD, technical design, costs and bill of materials, and sensible tests and simulations. This is a new development, not a copy of existing products.

Open hardware, CERN-OHL-W 2.0

Project log: 4 updates as text

Research v1.2

Design v1.8 is not in the inputs, so its figures (roof width 0.684 m, roof height 1.39 m, weight estimate 20 to 22 kg) come only from the project lead message and were not checked against a drawing. Primary sources confirm a 700 mm maximum PAB width and a 20 kg unladen limit, and both include attached accessories, so the roof, front rain screen, solar cells and mounts count toward both limits. The weight estimate of 20 to 22 kg is above the 20 kg limit across almost all of its range; the design would need about 2 kg less to clear the upper bound, which is a decision for Ben and the concept. …

  • Design v1.8 is missing from the inputs: only the project lead figures were used. Roof-level width 0.684 m is 16 mm under the 700 mm limit; the whole-vehicle width is not known.
  • Weight: the 20 kg limit includes attached accessories, so roof, front screen, solar cells and mounts count. The 20 to 22 kg estimate is ABOVE the limit: at 21 kg it is 1 kg over, at 22 kg 2 kg over; …
  • Width: 700 mm confirmed (S 251/2018 reg 3B; LTA PAB01; handbook p.21). S 355/2026, in operation 1 June 2026, keeps the number and counts attached accessories.
  • Construction: 'similar to that of a conventional bicycle' (OneMotoring; PAB01 'no horizontal platform between the 2 wheels; no excessive body panels'). Undefined in the texts; the two-ring V frame …

Design study v1.8

Rooficle, Design study v1.8: Main view: V-ring concept, front three-quarter

A first concept study of a V-ring design: two closed metal loops that form one loop from the side, with a solar roof on top and a front screen from the roof edge to the handlebar. The rings tilt 17 degrees each, which gives a 0.684 m overall width at the roof, just under the 0.70 m limit. The main open risks are the PAB construction rule (conventional bicycle) and weight, estimated at 20 to 22 kg against the 20 kg limit.

  • Side view reads as one loop: roof on top, front screen to the handlebar, saddle hanging at the rear.
  • From front or rear the two rings form a V, together at the bottom bracket and about 0.64 m apart at the roof.
  • Ring tilt is 17 degrees, not the 5 to 10 degrees Ben guessed; 5 to 10 degrees would give only 0.18 to 0.37 m at the roof.
  • Rain protection runs from the roof front edge down to the handlebar.

Research v1.1

Research v1.1 answers the rear-connection requirement for Singapore. A PAB may carry an adult pillion aged 16 or older (LTA handbook p.70, with helmets compulsory on roads), but a child seat conflicts with that 16+ rule as written and needs LTA confirmation. Whether a quick-release box counts toward the 20 kg limit is not settled; mounts, racks and fixed seats do count (handbook p.21). With an adult pillion and box, a 250 W bike stays at 25 km/h on flat roads but drops below that on grades of about 1.5 to 2.7 %, and the front brake alone is weak. The lightest commercial 20 in 250 W bike …

  • Passenger: adult pillion (16+) permitted under LTA handbook p.70; helmets compulsory on roads (p.30).
  • Child seat: conflicts with the 16+ pillion rule as written; LTA confirmation needed before any child-seat feature.
  • Box and rack: attached mounts, rack and fixed pillion seat count toward 20 kg (p.21); a quick-release box is unverified.
  • Load (own): flat 25 km/h fits in all cases (143 to 198 W); with rider, pillion and box, sustained grade falls to about 1.5 to 2.7 %.

Research v1.0

Research for Rooficle (Singapore) is complete as a first pass. Singapore PABs must stay at 250 W continuous, 25 km/h assist cut-off, 20 kg unladen, 0.70 m width and 2.6 m length, and use pedal-assist only; the 20 kg limit is already exceeded by concept v1.1's fixed-roof variants. Under own calculations, 0.5–1.0 m² of 16% flexible modules gives about 0.26–0.53 kWh/day (17–53 km/day at vendor consumption). A roofed bike parked on its stand may tip at 46–59 km/h, inside the documented squall range. Several points remain open (2026 rule change, battery certification, roof counting toward 20 kg), …

  • PAB limits (LTA PAB01 and handbook v1.1): 250 W continuous, 25 km/h assist cut-off, 20 kg unladen, width 0.70 m, length 2.6 m, EN 15194, pedal-assist only, cycling paths and roads only.
  • Concept v1.1 fixed-roof variants (21.5 kg, 21.1 kg) exceed 20 kg; only the roof-and-box-removed variant (19.7/19.2 kg) is below, and removable parts counting is unconfirmed.
  • Roof must keep the 'similar to conventional pedal bicycle' character: no platform, no excessive body panels; no modification of frame, handlebar, battery, motor or cables; no accessories drawing PAB …
  • Solar (own): about 0.53 kWh/day per m² of 16% module area at 4.33 kWh/m²/day irradiance and 76% performance ratio; 0.5–1.0 m² gives 0.26–0.53 kWh/day.