Blog · · 5 min read

BBQ grill design: heat, tipping and parts you can replace

What a charcoal grill has to survive, and how to design one where every part can be bought and replaced on its own: steel that grows when hot, coatings that burn, legs that must not tip, and one shared socket. Lessons from an open-hardware modular kettle.

A grill looks like the simplest product in the garden: a bowl, a lid, three legs. But when one part breaks, a bent leg, a lost handle, a rusted ash pan, the whole grill often goes to the dump, because the part is not sold on its own or no longer fits.

The BBQ Modular Grill, an open-hardware project on makemachine.ai, starts from that problem and adds a gift idea. A group of friends gives one grill together. Each person pays for one part, in their own colour and engraved with their name. Later, any broken part can be bought again and clicked into the rest.

That sounds like a marketing idea. It turns out to be an engineering brief, and a strict one.

The real product is the joint

The project is a 57 cm charcoal kettle made of nine core modules: hub ring, leg set, bowl, fire set, cooking grate, lid, handle pair, ash set and side table. Each one must be sold, shipped and engraved on its own. And each one must fit every other module, including a spare bought years later from a different batch.

So the most important drawing is not the bowl. It is the joint.

The concept compared several layouts and recommended a ring hub. One stainless ring carries 12 identical sockets. Legs, handles, side table and a lid holder click in with spring buttons, without tools. Four sockets stay free for add-ons. The bowl drops into the ring and locks with a 15° bayonet turn.

One socket type has a price: its dimensions can never change. Once the first grills are sold, every new leg and every future add-on must hit the same sizes. In a modular product, the socket drawing is the promise to every owner.

Heat changes the fit

Steel grows when it gets hot. Common austenitic stainless steels grow by about 17 micrometres per metre for every degree, ordinary carbon steel by about 12. That sounds small. Across a 570 mm bowl, 200 degrees more means roughly 2 mm more diameter in austenitic stainless and about 1.4 mm in carbon steel.

A bayonet that turns nicely in the garage can bind, or rattle, at full heat. It gets harder where two materials meet. In this design an enamelled bowl sits in a stainless ring, and the two run at different temperatures and grow at different rates. The fit has to work in the hot state as well as the cold one, and at the moment someone wants to open it while it is still warm.

Heat also decides where colour can go. Lid and bowl get their colour from enamel, which is glass fused onto the steel at around 800 °C and takes the heat of the fire. Powder coat is kept to the legs and the table frame. The ring, grates, fire and ash parts stay uncoloured.

Even that split needed a second look. The concept assumed the powder coat would hold 150 °C. The research step put the safe figure for standard powder coating at a conservative 100 °C. Any powder-coated part close to the bowl has to stay below that.

Names follow the same logic. Each module has one fixed name field: deep laser engraving on stainless, wood or powder coat, and a movable stainless badge on the enamelled lid and bowl. A side effect: a name survives even if the bowl is replaced one day.

A hot grill must not fall over

A tipped charcoal grill throws embers across a deck. In Europe, the standard for charcoal barbecues, EN 1860-1 (current edition 2024), has its own clause on stability, and test labs check it.

The CAD model checks this before any metal is cut. The grill weighs 33.8 kg, has a cooking height of 790 mm and stands 1,131 mm tall. In all five load cases it tips only beyond 10.4°. Ten states of use and assembly were checked for collisions, and none were found.

Snap-in legs add a risk a welded grill does not have. The 29 hand calculations found the lowest safety factor, 1.67, at the leg spigot, where the leg plugs into the ring. That is a useful result at this stage. The weakest point is the joint, not the bowl, so the first physical tests should load the joint, many times and hot.

Spare parts are not a given today

The research looked at how repairable kettle grills are now. Only two of the large brands sell most parts of a 57 cm kettle separately with EU prices, and one of them promises parts only for the warranty period. "Just buy the missing part" is not something buyers can count on.

It also checked the gift side. Group-gift platforms pool money and collect digital messages. None that the research found personalises a physical item per giver and ships the parts to several people.

The catch: one-offs cost what one-offs cost

The numbers are honest about the gap. A hand-made one-off of the nine core modules would cost about €2,700 net, far above the retail target of €760 to €1,150 for the core set. That gap is normal: parts made one at a time cost far more than the same parts in a series run. The prototype is there to test the joints and the heat, not the price.

Sourcing showed where the next work is. Of 61 item codes, 29 have no second source yet, and several parts are still placeholders. Nothing has been ordered.

What the AI did, and what it left open

Five steps were done with AI on makemachine.ai: the concept with options, market research, a draft patent application (not filed), the parametric CAD model with collision, tipping and load checks, and a sourcing draft. The research also flagged where the concept was too optimistic, as with the coating temperature.

What the AI did not do is decide. The target prices are estimates, and a person sets the final numbers. Coating limits and second sources need confirming with real suppliers before anything is ordered.

Checklist for a grill, or any product with hot parts

  • Define the joints first, and freeze their dimensions
  • Design every fit for the hot state and for mixed materials
  • Put colour and names only where the finish can take the heat
  • Check tipping with load cases, not only with the empty grill
  • Expect the weakest point at the joints, and test there first
  • Treat the prototype price as a prototype price

You can follow the project, with its concept, research and CAD, at BBQ Modular Grill. How to choose between printing, machining and molding for first parts is in 3D print, CNC or mold?, and why a first parts list costs more than expected is in What will my prototype cost? If you have an idea of your own, you can describe it here.

Watch hardware get built by AI. Follow public projects on makemachine.ai, read every result in full and get an email when there is something new.

Get started See the live projects

More from the blog

Open-hardware projects built with AI