Blog · · 5 min read

Kamado temperature control: the fire needs little air, so the fan's flap matters more than the fan

A ceramic kamado holds heat for hours, which makes it steady and slow to recover from an overshoot. How much air a low-and-slow fire really needs, why a small leak can outrun the fan, and what a flap that closes on its own does for a DIY fan controller.

A kamado is a heavy ceramic grill with a tight lid, a draft door at the bottom and a vent on top. The heavy wall is why people love it for long cooks: once it is warm, the temperature barely moves. It is also why a fan controller on a kamado needs care. A kamado that runs 30 degrees too hot stays too hot for a long time.

This article works through the numbers: how much air a low-and-slow fire needs, what a small leak does, and why the flap on the fan outlet decides whether the controller is safe. The example is the DIY BBQ Temperature Controller, an open-hardware project on makemachine.ai. Its research step found that people search a lot for kamado temperature control, but the results are mostly shop pages.

The fire needs less air than you think

Here is a rough estimate. Treat it as an order of magnitude, not a measurement. Assume a kamado at 110 to 120 °C burns about 0.3 kg of lump charcoal per hour, and the charcoal is about 80 % carbon.

  • 0.3 kg/h × 0.8 = 0.24 kg of carbon per hour.
  • Burning 1 kg of carbon to CO₂ takes 2.67 kg of oxygen, so 0.64 kg of oxygen per hour.
  • Air is about 23 % oxygen by mass, so that is 2.8 kg of air per hour, about 2.3 m³/h, or 1.4 CFM.

Even if you double that because air and charcoal never mix perfectly, the fire needs about 3 CFM or less. Fans sold for kamado controllers are typically rated from about 5 to 15 CFM of free air, some much more. At low and slow, the fan runs only in short pulses. Most of the time, the controller's job is to wait.

So anything else that lets air in competes directly with the fan.

A leak the size of a fingertip

A hot grill is a small chimney. The hot air inside is lighter than the air outside, so it rises out of the top vent and pulls fresh air in at the bottom. The pull is Δp = g · h · (ρ outside − ρ inside). For 0.5 m of height, 30 °C outside and 120 °C inside, it is about 1.3 Pa.

That is tiny, but through a 1 cm² gap it still drives up to about 0.3 m³/h of air (flow coefficient 0.6), roughly a seventh of what the fire needs. A tired gasket or a draft door left a few millimetres open quickly adds up to the whole demand. Then the fire burns at its own pace, the fan stays off, and the controller can only watch the temperature climb. Grill forums call this runaway temperature.

The fan port itself is the biggest possible leak. An open 40 mm port is 12.6 cm². With the full chimney pull behind it, that is more air than the whole fire needs. A stopped blower slows the flow, but it is not a closed valve.

Hence the usual setup: the draft door is closed except for the fan port, the top vent is nearly closed, and the fan becomes the main way air gets in.

The flap that closes by its own weight

The project's concept compared three ways to bring air to the fire and recommended a gravity flap. A small 12 V blower pushes a light flap open. When the fan stops, the flap falls shut by its own weight. A power cut, a pulled cable or a crashed controller all end the same way: with less air, not more. A fire with less air cools down, which is the safe direction.

Two pressures set the flap. It must stay shut against the chimney pull, which is about 1.3 Pa at low and slow and about 2.7 Pa with 300 °C inside. And it must open easily when the fan runs. The flap in the project opens at 18.3 Pa. That is more than ten times the pull at low and slow, and still a pressure a small radial blower reaches easily.

The rest is detail work. The flap sits in a stainless cartridge, and the slot cover and pin ends are sealed with heat-proof silicone, so nothing leaks past the closed flap at nominal size. When open, the flap stays 1.12 mm away from the bore wall. That clearance matters because ash and grease reach the vent too. A flap that rubs can stick open, and then the one safe failure the design depends on is gone.

One spigot for many grills

Draft doors differ from maker to maker, and kettles, bullet smokers and offsets differ again. The project puts the same 40 mm spigot on every adapter, and the fan head pushes onto it with a silicone coupler. The fan head with its flap is built and tested once; only a simple adapter changes from grill to grill.

A heavy grill wants a slow start

A common 18-inch ceramic kamado weighs roughly 70 kg, most of it in the walls. That mass smooths out wind, but makes the grill slow to come back down once it is too hot. Owners usually advise a slow climb and a long heat-soak; a fan running flat out from a cold start tends to overshoot.

The project's control loop is built around this:

  • Ramp the set point slowly and cap the fan at the start. In the concept's simple model, this cut the start-up overshoot from about +32 K to +0.9 K. The price is about an hour to reach 120 °C. That is a fair trade for a ten-hour cook.
  • Pause the fan when the lid opens. Otherwise the loop sees the sudden drop and blows in air that flares up when the lid closes.
  • Switch the fan off when the pit probe fails. No reading means no air.
  • Raise an alarm when the fire dies, because the fan then runs longer and longer while the temperature still falls.

The first article in this series covers the probes and the loop in more detail.

Checklist for a kamado fan

  1. Close every other air path: gasket, draft door, fan port.
  2. Set the top vent nearly closed and make the fan the main inlet.
  3. Fit a flap that closes by itself and opens only well above the chimney pull.
  4. Leave clearance around the flap and use heat-proof materials near the ceramic.
  5. Ramp up slowly and cap the fan at the start.
  6. Pause the fan when the lid opens and stop it on a probe fault.

How makemachine.ai handles it

On makemachine.ai, a project grows one step at a time. For this controller, concept, research and mechanical design are done. The mechanical step checked 29 moving states, flap open and closed among them, without a single collision. Electronics, sourcing and a presentation come next on the project page.

Watch hardware get built by AI. Follow public projects on makemachine.ai, read every result in full and get an email when there is something new.

Get started See the live projects

More from the blog

Open-hardware projects built with AI